Guides › Guide
Index funds vs ETFs in NZ: what's the difference?
Index funds and ETFs both track a market cheaply. Here is how they differ in New Zealand: how you buy, fees, tax (PIE vs FIF) and which suits you.
Key points
- Both usually track an index, like the top 500 US companies, for a low yearly fee.
- An ETF trades on a stock exchange like a share. An index fund is bought directly from the fund manager or a platform.
- NZ-based funds are usually PIEs (simple tax). Overseas ETFs can fall under FIF.
| NZ index fund (PIE) | NZ-listed ETF | US-listed ETF | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you buy | From the manager or a fund platform | On the NZX through a broker | On a US exchange through a broker |
| Trading cost | Often none | Brokerage | Brokerage + FX fee |
| Yearly fee | Low to medium | Low to medium | Often very low |
| Tax | PIE (taxed at your PIR) | Usually PIE | FIF rules may apply over $50,000 |
| Price | Once a day | Live during market hours | Live during US hours |
Which suits you?
- Regular small amounts: an NZ index fund avoids brokerage.
- Simple tax: PIE funds or NZ-listed ETFs.
- Lowest yearly fee, bigger amounts: US-listed ETFs, if you are fine with FX fees and FIF.
More detail: ETFs explained · PIE funds and PIR · FIF tax.
Frequently asked questions
Are ETFs or index funds better in NZ?
Neither is always better. Index funds suit regular small investing with no brokerage. ETFs suit people who want to trade on an exchange or reach overseas funds.
Are NZ-listed ETFs PIEs?
Most are, which keeps tax simple. Check the fund's product disclosure statement.
Last checked: November 2026